A Decision Framework for Bristol Business Leaders
Managed IT support is usually the stronger choice for businesses of 20 to 100 staff, because it gives you a whole team, 24/7 monitoring and a predictable cost for less than the loaded cost of a full-time hire. In-house IT earns its place when your environment needs someone on site every day, and plenty of businesses end up with a mix of both. Six factors decide it.
This guide is for owners and directors facing the decision, whether you’re replacing an IT manager who is leaving, thinking about a first IT hire or reviewing an outsourced arrangement. If you want to see what a managed service looks like, take a look at our Managed IT services.
The Key Takeaways
- The decision is about which responsibilities to own, share or outsource, not a binary choice.
- Six factors decide it: total cost, resilience, skills, security, strategic leadership and control.
- For 20 to 100 staff, managed support usually wins on cost, cover and breadth of skills.
- Co-managed IT combines an internal lead with an external provider and removes single-point-of-failure risk.
- Keep governance in place whichever route you choose: a roadmap, reporting and regular reviews.
Start With the Decision You Are Actually Making
The choice is rarely “outsource everything” or “hire a team”. It is a question of which responsibilities you want to own, which you want to share and how much risk you are willing to carry. Framing it that way opens up the options, including co-managed models covered later.
The Six Factors That Decide It
1. Total Cost
An in-house hire costs more than salary. Add employer National Insurance, pension, holiday and sickness cover, equipment, training, recruitment and the tools they need, such as monitoring, security and backup software.
A managed provider spreads tooling and team costs across many clients and charges a predictable monthly fee, which makes budgeting easier and strengthens the business benefits of the comparison. For many businesses, choosing an IT service provider is a cost effective way to gain access to specialised expertise without building the same capability in-house. For most SMEs this is cheaper than a single full-time hire, particularly once you need more than one skill set. Costs vary by business, so model it with your own figures.
Cost savings and cost predictability depend on organisation size, service scope, and how the provider structures charges. Managed support can also reduce unpredictable costs compared with relying on an in-house team for emergency fixes, recruitment, and tooling. Our guide to what managed IT support costs explains the pricing models.
2. Resilience and Cover
One employee takes holiday, gets ill and eventually leaves. When they do, your IT stops or your knowledge walks out. Documented systems also mean routine maintenance and proactive monitoring can reduce downtime and help boost productivity.
3. Breadth of Skills
One person cannot be an expert in networking, security, Microsoft 365, backup, hardware and compliance, while a provider gives you access to specialised skills and IT experts for each area. A provider fields a team with different specialisms, so you get the right person for each problem. That breadth helps close knowledge gaps and gives you access to advanced technology without having to recruit every capability in-house.
Microsoft 365 is a good example: with the right support, its integrated tools can boost productivity, improve collaboration, provide cloud storage for easy file access, and use automated workflows to save time on repetitive tasks.
4. Security
Security demands constant attention, and a proactive approach combines patching, threat monitoring, and robust security measures to protect sensitive data. Providers invest in security tooling and training, then spread the cost. The National Cyber Security Centre’s small business guide lists the basics every organisation should have in place, and a managed provider can deliver and maintain them. Good cyber security support helps reduce the risk of data breaches and can help ensure regulatory compliance. Our Managed IT services page covers how we do this.
5. Strategic Leadership
Whether the person leading your IT is internal or external, someone needs to own the roadmap, budget and supplier decisions. A junior in-house hire rarely provides this. A provider can offer it through regular reviews, while a more senior leadership layer is available through IT consultancy. Strong IT governance aligns IT strategy with business goals for compliance, as well as budget and supplier control. That helps leadership spend less time on routine IT administration and more time on strategic initiatives.
6. Knowledge and Control
This is where an in-house team or IT department often shines. Someone who works alongside your team understands your internal resources, business needs and day-to-day priorities better than anyone external, and you have direct control over priorities. A good support provider narrows the gap through an IT partnership with the existing IT team or internal IT team, with clear roles and open communication.
This can supplement IT resources rather than replace them when a changing business puts pressure on capacity. Businesses should also feel confident in the relationship before handing key systems to an external company. Our longest client relationship has lasted over 20 years, and our managed IT support is built to keep relationships like that going.
How the Answer Changes With Size
As a rough guide rather than a rule:
- Around 20 to 40 staff. A full-time hire is hard to justify and hard to cover. Many businesses at this size prefer managed support because it gives broader coverage than an in-house team at lower cost.
- Around 40 to 100 staff. Managed support still suits most, with some businesses adding an internal lead for coordination. Co-managed models fit well, so you can keep an internal IT team while using a provider to add capacity and specialist coverage.
- 100 staff and above, or complex specialist systems. In-house capability becomes more viable, often supported by a provider for security, monitoring and cover, but fully managed support can still be the right fit where 24/7 monitoring, security and infrastructure support are priorities.
Sector and systems matter as much as headcount. A business running specialist line-of-business software or operational technology may need on-site expertise earlier.
How to Model the Cost Fairly
Use your own numbers and compare the same service scope on both sides, because broader support services usually cost more.
- In-house. Salary, employer costs, pension, training, tooling and software, recruitment, cover for absence and an allowance for the time you spend managing them.
- Managed. The fixed monthly fee for predictable costs, onboarding, any out-of-scope work and licences if billed separately.
- Add the risk. A realistic cost for the weeks your IT would be uncovered if the hire left, plus the impact on business operations of a failed backup or a missed patch.
The Third Option: Co-Managed IT
You don’t always have to choose. Co-managed IT is a partnership between your internal IT team and a managed service provider, adding specialised expertise without replacing internal ownership. The provider adds monitoring, security, out-of-hours cover and specialist projects, while the internal person focuses on what is unique to your business.
It suits businesses that already have an IT person and want support when workloads, security demands or knowledge gaps exceed available internal resources, without a large hiring programme. CAB IT works as a co-managed partner in this way, supporting IT teams rather than replacing them, with service providers’ tools, coverage and custom solutions built around the existing setup.
Governance, Whichever Route You Choose
Whichever model you pick, keep the same disciplines in place:
- A written roadmap and budget reviewed at least annually.
- Monthly reporting on response times, patching, backup, security, IT operations and IT infrastructure performance.
- Documented systems, so knowledge is not held by one individual.
- Agreed response times and escalation routes.
- A regular review meeting with someone at director level. A good managed IT service provides all of this as standard.
Questions to Ask Before You Decide
- What would it cost us if IT was down for a day?
- If our IT person left tomorrow, how long before we recovered?
- Who is responsible for security and backup today?
- Do we need onsite support daily, or only occasionally?
- Are our current support companies or service providers delivering high quality services and the service quality we expect?
- Are we growing, and will our IT resources scale with changing business needs?
- Who owns our IT roadmap and budget?
- Do customers, insurers or tenders expect formal security controls?
- Can we afford an in-house team or IT department large enough for cover and a range of skills?
If most answers point to risk or cost, managed IT support is likely the safer choice.
Making the Move
If you decide to outsource, a good support provider will make the switch straightforward, even if you already have an existing IT team. At CAB IT, we audit your set-up, deploy monitoring tools and security in the background, and go live, usually in about a week with no downtime. Open communication with the support provider helps keep the service aligned with your business needs during the handover.
Read more in our Switch to CAB guide, or see how we approach IT support in Bristol. When you are ready, you can book a conversation through our Managed IT services page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is managed IT support cheaper than in-house IT?
For most small and medium businesses, yes. A full-time hire involves salary, employment costs, training and tools, and still cannot provide 24/7 cover or every specialism. A managed provider gives you a team for a fixed monthly fee, with better cost-effectiveness through lower staffing overhead and more predictable support services. Model it with your own figures.
When should a business hire in-house IT staff?
Hire in-house when you have complex systems needing daily on-site attention, a large estate or a requirement to keep all IT knowledge internally. Most businesses of this type still benefit from external support for security and out-of-hours cover, while firms that do not need daily onsite presence may be better served by a fully managed model.
Can I use both managed IT support and an in-house IT person?
Yes. This is called co-managed IT. Your internal person handles day-to-day, business-specific work, while the provider supplies monitoring, security, specialist skills and cover for absence, helping free up time for core activities and core business activities.
What happens if my in-house IT person leaves?
Without documentation and backup cover, your IT can be left without anyone who understands it. Managed providers document your systems and have multiple engineers, so this risk is much lower.
Is managed IT support secure?
A good provider improves security by monitoring continuously, applying updates, protecting devices and training staff. They also use automation tools and network management as part of a proactive security and reliability model. Look for recognised accreditations, such as NCSC Assured Service Provider status, and alignment with Cyber Essentials.